Home
About
Aus Greens
NSW Greens
Contact Us
Resources
Pictures

SSG Topics
Bullet4 Indigenous
Bullet4 Elections
Bullet4 Development
Bullet4 Water
Bullet4 Money
Bullet4 Climate Change
Bullet4 Conservation
Bullet4 Corruption
Bullet4 Council Elections
Bullet4 Democracy
Bullet4 Drugs
Bullet4 Education
Bullet4 Food
Bullet4 Foreign Affairs
Bullet4 Forests
Bullet4 Health
Bullet4 Housing
Bullet4 IR & Unions
Bullet4 Justice
Bullet4 LGBTI
Bullet4 Middle East
Bullet4 Nuclear
Bullet4 Pollution & Waste
Bullet4 Poverty
Bullet4 Refugees
Bullet4 Renewable Energy
Bullet4 Science & Tech
Bullet4 Transport
Bullet4 Women


 
Climate Change:
Discounting the Productivity Commission on Stern
Friday, 25 January 2008, Crikey
Australian Greens Climate Change Spokesperson, Senator Christine Milne

The Productivity Commission's clear attempt this morning to influence the outcome of the Garnaut Review may be couched in detached and academic language, but its implications are profound.

The Commission's characterisation of the Stern Review as advocacy rather analysis can be equally applied to this morning's Staff Paper and much of what has been published by this so-called politically neutral and independent body over many years.

We mustn't forget that the economic troglodytes at the Productivity Commission put out a 500 page report in August 2005 the main thrust of which was that any energy efficiency opportunities that exist must largely have already been fully taken advantage of. This is patently wrong. In fact, most experts recognise that increasing efficiency is the cheapest and fastest way of reducing emissions.

Much of the critique in today's Productivity Commission staff paper lies in the application of a discount rate to the value of human life, and the Commission is quite right to say that this is an ethical and moral question. But surely the basic assumption, as Stern concluded, must be that a life today is equivalent to a life tomorrow, and there should be a close to zero discount rate applied. Stern's rate of 0.1% for human life takes into account the risk of the human race descending to extinction. I am one with the UK Tories, whose Blueprint for a Green Economy argues that Stern is "too complacent" in his estimates of climate impacts and emissions reduction targets, and his discount rate is too high.

Anyone putting forward models that value a human death in 50 years time as only 5% of its current worth, as would be the case with a 6% discount rate, is putting forward a position so divergent from cultural norms that it is surely more advocacy than analysis.

While the Productivity Commission is not advocating one value rather than another in today's paper, their suggestion that the discount rate should be higher rather than lower is clearly part of their ongoing advocacy campaign to undermine climate action.

If the Productivity Commission staff bothered to follow climate science, they would realise that Stern's choice of the IPCC's upper band of warming is now being proven to be conservative. Climate impacts are shooting ahead of the projections, leaving policy way behind. Now is not the time for more rearguard action to delay emissions cuts.


Related links:
Story found at : Bullet4 tinyurl.com/26zzfo

 Printerfriendly display Printerfriendly display    
 
Coming Events
<< March 2010 >>
S M T W T F S
28 01 02 03 04 05 06
07 08 09 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31 01 02 03

Today's Events

No Events


Upcoming Events

Wed, March 24 2010
Tue, April 20 2010
Wed, April 28 2010
Tue, May 18 2010
Wed, May 26 2010
Tue, June 15 2010
Wed, June 23 2010


[ Search ]

Councillor Chris Harris


At a Council meeting on the 15th of March, the Lord Mayor moved a mayoral minute (delivered to councillors 25 minutes before the meeting), which was supported Clover Moore Party “independents” and the Liberal Councillor, to abandon plans to build a skate park at the Millers Point site underneath a busy freeway (for background information on the site, [...]

I have serious concerns about the tender process that appears to have been designed to place the City’s tennis courts under the management of a single operator. Should the recommendation of council staff be adopted the operator at Ruchcutters Bay tennis courts will be tossed out after 25 years of service to the community. The [...]

Hot on the heels of their destruction of the habitat area at Orphan School Creek with the freshly laid concrete zig zag path, the Clover Moore Party are at it again across the road in Johnstons Canal with more habitat destruction.  The proposal is a bike path that links the shared pathway emerging from Orphan [...]

The Barangaroo Authority conducted a presentation of the design ideas of British architect Richard Rogers at the City Recital Hall on 23rd February. The presentation visuals showed attractive buildings and public spaces that interfaced with the water at the city’s western edge with a light rail service passing down Hickson Rd. One key component of the [...]

At a council meeting of the City of Sydney on 22nd February Clover Moore Party members and the Liberal councilor voted in tandem to donate public ratepayer funds to two private enterprises setting up in the City’s laneways. The first donation to set up a new bar was approved outright.  The second grant, to the Moran Arts Foundation Ltd, was recommended [...]